Winnipeg Architecture Foundation

People

Architects

Edgar Prain

  • 1881 - 1958
  • MAA

Biography

In his over forty-five years of architectural practice in Winnipeg, Edgar Prain was a highly active figure responsible for a large number of apartment blocks, churches, private residences, and educational buildings. He is also noteworthy for having founded an eponymous firm (later to become Prain and Ward, Ward Macdonal and finally MCM Architects) which would go on to be one of the city’s oldest. Prain was born in the Scottish burgh of Broughty Ferry on 21 March 1881; at a young age he articled with architect T.S. Robertson in nearby Dundee, from 1896 to 1901, tutelage which was followed by work as a draftsman for Glasgow architect Hugh Barclay. Prain relocated to London in 1902; here he was hired by the London County Council Architect's Department. With the Department Prain engaged in the design of numerous housing projects over a five year period.

In 1908 the architect emigrated to Canada, settling in Winnipeg. Upon his arrival here Prain initially formed a partnership with architect Hugh G. Holman (from 1909-10); in 1912, however, the architect established a firm under his own name. This office specialized in residential projects as well as schools and religious buildings. Typical projects include the one and half storey, somewhat Arts & Crafts style Duff Residence (15 St. James Street), the red brick with limestone base Acadia Apartments (351 Victor Street, 1911) and Verona Apartments (730 Victor Street, Winnipeg, 1911) and the similar James B. Brown Company Factory (902 Home Street, 1912). These projects straddle a line between a certain traditionalism while embracing modern construction techniques and some contemporary aesthetic trends.

One particularly significant commission of this era was the limestone neo-Gothic design of St. John's Anglican Cathedral (135 Anderson Avenue, Winnipeg, 1925-26; with Gilbert Parfitt). Early post-war work by Prain – such as Powell Equipment Company (1060 Arlington Street, 1945) and Deer Lodge United Church (2093 Portage Avenue, 1946) demonstrate the architect’s continued reliance on brick alongside a clear move toward a more modernist idiom. In 1949 Prain’s office was joined by James Thomas Laurence Ward, a University of Manitoba Bachelor of Architecture graduate who had previously worked at the university and with the firm of Moody and Moore. Shortly after being hired Ward was made junior partner and, in 1951, the firm was re-named Prain and Ward.

In December 1957 Prain retired after having served for some time as a consultant; the following year Gerald D. Macdonald, a native Winnipegger and 1953 graduate of the University of Manitoba School of Architecture, was made a partner and the firm was again renamed, becoming Ward Macdonald. Prain passed away that January. Prain had served as president of the Manitoba Association of Architects in 1939.

Projects

  • Scott Residence, 190 Kingsway Avenue, 1910
  • David A. Duff Residence, 15 St. James Street, 1911
  • Acadia Apartments, 351 Victor Street, 1911
  • Verona Apartments, 730 Victor Street, 1911
  • J. Farquahar Residence, Greenwood Place, 1911
  • Prain Residence, Walnut Street, 1911
  • James B. Brown Company Factory, 902 Home Street, 1912
  • Scott Apartments, Maryland Street, 1912
  • Lanark Apartments, Maryland Street, 1912
  • Reliance Block Apartments, Young Street, 1912
  • Lutheran Academy, Melville, Saskatchewan, 1913
  • Apartment block for J. Johannesson, Young Street, 1913
  • Apartment block for J.J. Swanson, Maryland Street near Sargent Avenue, 1913
  • Semple School, Jefferson Avenue, 1913
  • Centennial School, Main Street at Royal Avenue, 1913 (since demolished)
  • Westholm Apartments, Wellington Avenue, 1913
  • Elvira Court Apartments, Emily Street, 1914
  • Salisbury School, 795 Prince Rupert Avenue, 1920
  • Cathedral Church of St. John, 135 Anderson Avenue, 1926
  • Two apartment blocks for an unnamed client, Osborne Street, 1927
  • John Black Memorial United Church, 898 Henderson Highway, 1927
  • St. John’s Presbyterian Church, 251 Bannerman Avenue, 1928
  • Chalmers United Church, Spruce Street at Barrett Avenue, 1928 (demolished in 1977)
  • Apartment block, Broadway at Donald Street, 1938
  • Powell Equipment Company, 1060 Arlington Street, 1945
  • Deer Lodge United Church, 2093 Portage Avenue, 1946; addition, 1956 (now demolished)
  • United Church, 4 Main Street, Sanford, Manitoba, 1948-53
  • School for Selkirk District No. 68, Selkirk, Manitoba, 1949
  • MacLeod's Limited, 101st Street, Edmonton, Alberta, 1949
  • Public school for District No. 8, 1950

Sources

  • “The New Residence of David A. Duff.” Manitoba Free Press. 4 March 1911.
  • “Apartment Block.” Manitoba Free Press. 24 May 1911.
  • “A New Manufactury.” Manitoba Free Press. 9 November 1912.
  • “Centennial School in Kildonan.” Manitoba Free Press. 1 February 1913.
  • “Thirty New Apartment Blocks Being Built.” Manitoba Free Press, 2 August 1913.
  • “Untitled.” Construction xx (May 1927): 156.
  • “Untitled.” Construction xix (November 1926): 365
  • “Obituary: Edgar Prain.” Winnipeg Free Press. 30 January 1958.
  • “Obituary: Edgar Prain.” Winnipeg Tribune. 30 January 1958.
  • “Veteran architect Edgar Prain dies.” Winnipeg Free Press. 30 January 1958.
  • 50th Anniversary: John Black Memorial Church. Winnipeg: John Black Memorial Church, 1964. 37.
  • Historic Architecture of Saskatchewan. Regina: Saskatchewan Associaton of Architects. 1986. 147.
  • Bingham, Neil. Study of Church Buildings in Manitoba. Winnipeg: Department of Culture, Heritage and Recreation, Historic Resources Branch, 1987. 205, 238, 241.